Saturday, August 23, 2008

Braid: An Analysis


Screen grabs are taking from YouTube videos found here and here.
(Who knew doing screenshots and captions would be such a pain?)
Also, the NeoGAF thread is here and the GameFAQs thread is here.

Now that it’s been a couple of weeks since Braid came out and people have moved on to Bionic Commando, I think we have a chance to reflect on it outside of the “bubble”. As a game itself, Braid is a great platformer/puzzle game designed to give you as many attempts as you need to complete a puzzle. Small annoyances that would make you go crazy in traditional platformers – mistiming a jump being the most egregious mistake one can make – are removed by the simple fact that you can reverse time at any point and try again. Of course, the downside is that the ability to easily retry a section also encourages a frustrating grind (I spent an hour trying to grab a star!), but I think that’s a small price to pay for the tremendous accessibility that the game gives you.

As for the “content” in the game, I really didn’t want to do a close reading of any section of the game. By now, the Atom Bomb theory has passed around the Internet and all I really want to say about that is that I’m glad more people have been exposed to the process of close reading. Present evidence, deliver argument, then conclude. For whatever reason, this process seems to be difficult to teach to undergrads... so maybe they just need something obtuse that forces them to think and to come up with something on their own. The only real problem that I have with this close reading is that it doesn’t address the larger context of the game, including the introductory books that begin each world and the events in the game itself (killer rabbits and cute plush dinosaurs?), and there may be contradictions or inconsistencies with this reading if you were to bring these elements into the fold.

What I want to focus on is the use of the time reversal mechanic and how that influences the integration of gameplay and storytelling. For the moment, let’s take the story we are giving at face value. You play as Tim, a person who may have made some kind of mistake with a woman in the past and wants to reconnect with her. Time reversal gives Tim (hey, Time without the “e”. I can’t believe I just noticed that!) the opportunity to correct his mistakes and even change the nature of causality (as one of the books points out, why are people punished for mistakes instead of rewarded for the learning experience mistakes can provide?) , allowing him to overcome several thematic obstacles in order to reach the “princess” who we assume is the girl he has been pining for throughout the game.

Throughout the entire game, you assume a level of agency that you become familiar with. Yes, each world treats time differently, but as the player you can always depend on the X button to reverse time regardless of the situation you find yourself in. Indeed, you come to expect that you will be able to fix any mistake you make in the game by pressing the X button to reverse time for a few seconds. The game wants you to have this agency because it makes the actual ending (World 1-1, not the epilogue) that much more personal. In World 1-1, you finally meet the princess you’ve been looking for. You see what appears to be the boss character, a very large man, carry the princess down to a platform above you. She jumps free of his grasp and he becomes angry, sending a wall of flame toward you from the left. In this final world in the game, you essentially must run through a final obstacle course to escape the wall of flame and, implicitly, reach the princess at the end of this ordeal. Additionally, as you play through the world, you get the distinct impression that the princess is doing everything in her power to try to help you get through the obstacle course. She’ll flip switches that raises platforms or lowers obstacles, allowing you to pass through the obstacles. In fact, perhaps in a moment that references ICO, you have to trust the princess to flip the switches for you – the wall of flame is mere centimetres away from you and the only option you have is to jump into a pit of spikes. Without any option, you make the jump and just as you are about to die, the princess flips a switch and a platform suddenly rises from the ground, saving your life and allowing you to continue through the world.


As you approach the end of the map, you see the princess approach her bedroom and as you get closer to reaching her, she falls asleep in her bed. When you jump to the space just outside her bedroom, time suddenly freezes and you lose all control of the game. You aren’t told to do anything or if anything had actually happened and instinctively, you reach for the X button because you’ve been trained that pressing the X button will fix any problems. When you do press and hold the X button, the game suddenly resumes – but instead of reversing time, time actually progresses normally. If you release the X button, the game stops and will only continue if you hold the X button again. An ability that previously gave the player a tremendous amount of agency suddenly becomes suffocating, uncontrollable and most importantly, unreliable.

A scene in which it seemed as if the princess and the player were working together in order to escape the evil boss character and imminent death now becomes extremely warped and twisted. Rather than be the valiant hero trying to reach the princess, you end up being a creepy guy standing outside of a girl’s bedroom, staring at her as she sleeps. Eventually, she wakes up, notices you and runs away from you. You try to follow her, running the same obstacle course but this time in reverse. Everything is exactly the same, but the entire scene is replayed through a distorted perspective. Rather than try to help you through the obstacle course, the princess is now actively trying to stop you from completing the course by dropping obstacles in your path. Indeed, moments where you thought that the princess was trying to save you from death were actually moments where the princess was actively trying to kill you. When you reach the end (or beginning, depending on your perspective) of the world, you see the boss character shout at the princess. While you first thought that this character was evil and had kidnapped the princess, it actually turns out that this character is a valiant knight, saving the princess from the evil character – YOU. Eventually, the princess jumps into the knight’s arms and they escape off screen. At this point, you are given control again but the only thing you can do is go through a door and head toward the Epilogue world. From this sequence, it’s undeniable – you aren’t the hero trying to reach and rescue the princess, you are the villain that the princess needs rescuing from!


There is one small example in this sequence that I’d like to point out here, because it will help explain how I come to my ultimate conclusion. As you watch the scene unfold by holding the X button, you will get to a scene that will be familiar to you. When you first encountered this segment of the map during normal gameplay, you see that the princess hit a switch that rotated a wall that was blocking your path. When you return to this segment during the “hold X” portion of the game, you see that the princess flipped this switch in order to block you from using a ladder to reach her. This is an example of what I believe is one of the themes of the game – the revisionist nature of memory. Assuming that this sequence is what “really happens” in this game world, all of Tim’s time reversal power is simply Tim re-imagining his life experience in his head. Most of us have experienced a moment in our lives that we replay in our heads, trying to figure out how a situation would have unfolded differently if we had just said something or did something different and this is exactly what Tim has done throughout the entire game. Indeed, this is why World 1-1 is the last level of the game. At this point, you are in the “present” in the game’s temporal continuity and you, as Tim, have simply replayed Tim’s memories in your head, revising and optimizing his memory in the process. Maybe Tim tried to ask a girl out and she told him to fuck off before going home with another guy. In his head, he’s able to “reverse time” and fix this memory so that he’s able to convince the girl to stay with him.



Now, for most players, this is basically the end of the game. And as it stands, this ending alone is a rather noteworthy example of how ludic and narratological experiences can work together to tell an effective story to the player. After you exit the Epilogue world, you are dumped right back at the beginning of the game. Everything appears to be exactly the same, except in the night sky, you see a group of star outlines forming a constellation in the night sky. This is the only clue that you get that tells you that there is much, much more to the game.


So what do I make of the eight secret stars? There’s the metagame aspect that’s worth looking at for a moment. First and foremost there is no achievement for getting the stars. When you complete the game for the first time, the only achievement that is listed as incomplete is the speedrun achievement. Whereas Blow wanted people to try for an optimal run-through of the game (the official speedrun time is 45 minutes for the entire game) as a challenge for the player after the game was complete, he didn’t mind if people ended up missing this second layer of challenge. In fact, going by NeoGAF and GameFAQs, there were many players who did not know about the stars until reading them (myself included).

One poster at NeoGAF suggested that this was a way to poke fun or at least acknowledge obsessive gamers who are completionists or who try to find ways to break a game/find secrets. Indeed, the first star that you can get (in World 2) requires you to sit by the game for two hours as a slow moving cloud platform scrolls to the left side of the screen. It’s almost reminiscent of that cancelled Penn and Teller game where you had to drive a bus across the country in REAL TIME (8 hours one way) and you had to sit and hold the controller or the bus would crash and you would have to start over. Now, Blow isn’t that much of a sadist and as long as you glance up at the screen once in a while, you don’t have to babysit your controller. But it’s almost as if he expected you to find something else to occupy your time as you waited to get this star and I believe that Blow is trying to put you into the headspace of Tim. Just as Tim is determined to use whatever means he has available to him to reach the princess, you are willing to put in the extra effort to reach these stars even if you do not know what the end result will be.

Of course, the real rub is that one of the stars is only obtainable if you haven’t completed the puzzle pieces in World 3. This means that if you’ve played and finished the game, you’ll have to make use of the “restart game” option and start over from the beginning. This may be frustrating if you’ve already completed the game... but much more so if you’ve spent the time to try to obtain the other stars. But I think Blow did this expecting that most players would not see that star and would have to restart the game. This not only implicitly nudges the player toward completing a speedrun, but it is also another attempt to put the player into Tim’s mindset. As you play through the game a second time, you know all the solutions to the puzzles in the game and your sense of agency is tremendously increased. Not only do you have the power to reverse time, but you know exactly what will happen in the future as well. As the player you actually have MORE power than Tim since at this point, you have full control of time. Yes, you can’t fast forward time but since you know exactly what will happen (especially in World 4 when your movements dictate the how time flows), it is an implied prescience that Blow wants you to experience as you replay the game.

This new sense of power leads to the final star in the game which, not coincidentally, is found back in the last level in the game, World 1-1. You play through the exact same scene again, with you trying to get to the princess by navigating the obstacle course, but this time there is an important difference. You’ll notice that two of the switches are immune to the time reversal mechanic (this is the “glowing green” game mechanic introduced in World 3) and that these switches block off some of the obstacles that slow down your progress. This gives you the clue that you should be able to exploit the timing of the level by flipping the switches and using your time reversal powers. If done correctly, you literally break the timing of the level and are able to get to a location in the world well before you should be able to. Again this whole sequence requires you to know exactly what happens in the world beforehand, relying on your ability to “see into the future” in order to figure out that you have to break the timing of the level in the first place. When you do this, you are able to not only reach the princess but get into her bedroom as well, as this is where you’ll find the final star in the game.


The game’s original ending is both a comment on the futility of agency, your power to reverse time ultimately does not help you get to the princess, and hints at the revisionist nature of memory, as I suggested above with an analysis of what happens in the original ending. With this ending however, agency is completely restored to the player and the “optimal” reality is the one that prevails. I’m not sure what Blow is trying to suggest here. Perhaps this is meant to be inspirational – if you try hard enough, you will be able to reach the princess after all. But it may also hint at a darker message, that when the trauma of the “truth” is impossible to accept, you’ll keep trying to undo the truth in your own imagination until you are unable to see reality at all. For me, the message isn’t what’s remarkable about the game – lots of the games have tried to impart a message to the player. No, what’s remarkable is that all of this is done THROUGH gameplay without any dialogue or without relying on a cutscene. Not only is it left up to the player to find her own interpretation of the ending (nuclear bomb allegory or not), the player also CREATES this ending. By integrating both endings so tightly into the gameplay, the player almost becomes Blow’s co-writer and is fully involved in how the ending will unfold.

Ultimately, this is why I think the game is one of the more important texts of this generation of games. Blow pushes Ken Levine’s “story through gameplay” design choice in Bioshock further, not only allowing the player to create the ending but also a chance to interpret the ending as well. If I were to ever teach a course about ludology and narratology, this game would be at the top of my syllabus. Thankfully, a PC version of the game has been promised by Blow, but even if this wasn’t the case, I would make my students purchase an Xbox 360 in order to experience this moment in gaming history themselves. Braid gives me hope as both an enthusiast and an academic that games are close to a breakthrough that will finally show that games have their own mechanical and rhetorical storytelling devices.

4 comments:

Unknown said...

I'm getting ready to do a piece on Braid for a company I am trying to start. This is extremely helpful in helping me move away from the atomic bomb theory that is so prevalent that I always felt was a little flawed. Thanks to this post I have been able to come up with my own theories!

That said, I think you might be interested in my group. I want a large segment of what we do to be video material much like this article and I would love to collaborate with you.

pixel-addiction.net - another group we have merged with to get some infrastructure.

http://www.kickstarter.com/projects/syphontwo/triforge-gaming - our project page.

Just for a little on credentials, I am a masters student in Engineering with my undergrad in Art and Music History. Mos of my team is currently in their undergrad or starting soon.

Ruby said...


I was very interested in the article , it’s quite inspiring I should admit. I like visiting your site since I always come across interesting articles like this one. Keep sharing! Regards. Read more about
Offshore software testing services
software testing services company
software testing services
Software Qa Services
quality assurance service providers

sathya said...


We are providing the best master data services around the world.
selenium training in chennai |
Selenium Training in Chennai | Certification | Online Training Course | Selenium Training in Bangalore | Certification | Online Training Course | Selenium Training in Hyderabad | Certification | Online Training Course | Selenium Training in Coimbatore | Certification | Online Training Course | Selenium Training in Online | Certification | Online Training Course

Sophia Miz said...

So far out of all the blogs, I personally feel this blog is just awesome Excellent goods from you about Game Testing Services, man. I’ve understand your stuff previous to and you’re just too excellent on Game Testing Companies. I actually like what you’ve acquired here, certainly like what you are stating and the way in which you say it. You make it enjoyable and you still take care of to keep it sensible content about Game Testing Services USA. I can not wait to read far more Video Game Testing Companies from you. This is actually a tremendous site..